Judicial Review Attorneys South Africa | PAJA Review of Home Affairs Visa, PR & V-List Decisions in the High Court

PAJA · High Court review

Judicial Review – set aside unlawful decisions in the High Court

If Home Affairs refused you on the wrong law, ignored your evidence or denied you a fair process, the decision can be reviewed and set aside. We analyse the record, build the grounds under PAJA and take the matter to the High Court.

Bedfordview, Johannesburg & Cape Town Mon–Fri 08:00–17:00 Admitted attorneys, not consultants
High Court judicial review of Home Affairs decisions – Wentzel Immigration Attorneys
  • 40+ yearscombined legal experience
  • AttorneysHome Affairs to High Court
  • Two officesJohannesburg & Cape Town
  • Confidentialprivileged attorney advice

Quick answer

What is judicial review of a Home Affairs decision?

Judicial review is a High Court process that tests whether an administrative decision was lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair, as the Constitution and the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 (PAJA) require. Grounds include errors of law, failure to consider relevant evidence, irrationality, bias and unfair procedure.

Internal remedies such as Section 8 appeals generally must be exhausted first, and the review must usually be brought within 180 days after they are concluded. If successful, the court sets the decision aside and usually sends it back to be decided again lawfully – and in exceptional cases may substitute its own decision.

To speak to an attorney, call Johannesburg on 083 657 4311 or call Cape Town on 082 556 6502, or send your details.

Legal basis
PAJA & the Constitution
Time limit
Generally 180 days
Precondition
Internal remedies exhausted
Grounds
Unlawful, unreasonable, unfair
Outcome
Decision set aside / remitted
Our fees
Quoted per case after consultation

Decisions we review

Home Affairs decisions we take on review

Visa refusals

Temporary residence refusals upheld on appeal.

  • Work, business, spousal, study

Permanent residence refusals

Section 26 and 27 refusals after the Minister’s appeal.

  • Irrational reasoning

Waiver refusals

Section 31 decisions that ignore exceptional circumstances.

  • Unreasonableness

V-listing & undesirability

Refusals of section 29(2) and 30(2) applications.

  • Procedural fairness

ID blocking & PR withdrawal

Decisions taken without a fair hearing.

  • Audi alteram partem

Refugee decisions

Reviews of refugee status decisions where appropriate.

  • Refugees Act

Grounds of review

What makes a decision reviewable

Error of law

The official applied the wrong section, requirement or test.

Ignoring relevant evidence

Documents you submitted were overlooked or misread.

Irrationality

The reasons do not connect to the evidence or the outcome.

Procedural unfairness

No opportunity to respond to adverse information, or inadequate reasons.

Unreasonable delay or bias

Decisions affected by delay, bias or an improper purpose.

Avoid refusal

Review pitfalls

Missing the 180-day limit

Late reviews need condonation and may fail.

Skipping the appeal

Courts expect internal remedies first.

No record

We request the record of decision under Rule 53.

Re-arguing merits only

Review is about legality – the grounds must be framed correctly.

How it works

From first call to final outcome

One attorney-led process for every matter – the same care whether it is a visitor’s visa extension or a High Court application.

  1. Tell us your story

    Call, WhatsApp or send the form. We contact you, give you a booking date and confirm the consultation fee for your type of matter before anything is charged.

  2. Attorney consultation

    An attorney hears the full story, reads your documents and Home Affairs paperwork, and tells you honestly what the law allows – and what it does not.

  3. Written strategy

    You get the recommended route, the legal basis, a document checklist, realistic timelines and a written quote for the work – before work starts.

  4. Prepared, lodged, defended

    We draft the motivation, affidavits and legal submissions, check every page against the Act and Regulations, and lodge via VFS, Home Affairs or court.

  5. Tracked to the outcome

    We follow up with VFS, Home Affairs and the State Attorney, answer requests and, if a decision is wrong, take it on appeal or review.

Why Wentzel

Why an immigration attorney changes the outcome

Most refusals are avoidable, and most Home Affairs mistakes are fixable – if the right legal tools are used. That is the difference an attorney makes.

Attorneys, not agents

Immigration consultants can fill in forms. Admitted attorneys can also give privileged legal advice, sign court papers and take Home Affairs to the High Court when it gets a decision wrong.

40+ years of experience

The Wentzel practice started in 1994 advising foreign nationals in the Kempton Park courts. Today the brothers bring over four decades of combined experience to every file.

Litigation when it is needed

When appeals stall or Home Affairs simply does not decide, we bring mandamus and judicial review applications – an escalation path consultants cannot offer.

Johannesburg & Cape Town

A Bedfordview office for Gauteng and a Cape Town Consultation Facility at the V&A Waterfront – with consultations available nationally and online.

Honest from day one

If your case is weak, we say so before you spend money. If it is strong, we build it properly the first time – no shortcuts, no false promises.

Confidential & privileged

What you tell your attorney is protected by legal professional privilege. Your immigration history, family and finances stay between us.

What you needWentzel Immigration AttorneysTypical visa consultant
Give privileged legal advice Yes No
Draft affidavits & legal representations YesLimited
Bring High Court applications against Home Affairs Yes No
Defend immigration criminal charges Yes No
Regulated by the Legal Practice Council Yes No
Handle VFS visa & permit applications Yes Yes
40+Years combined experience
1994Wentzel practice founded
2Offices – JHB & Cape Town
3Levels: Home Affairs → Minister → Court

Speak to an immigration attorney

Tell us your story – we will contact you with a booking date for your consultation.

Book a Consultation

Your attorneys

The attorneys behind your case

Your matter is handled by admitted attorneys – the same people whose names are on the door.

Chris Wentzel – Co-Founder & Senior Attorney, Wentzel Immigration Attorneys

Chris Wentzel

Co-Founder & Senior Attorney

Jaenrè Botha – Associate Attorney, Wentzel Immigration Attorneys

Jaenrè Botha

Associate Attorney

Hermie Wentzel – Co-Founder & Senior Attorney, Wentzel Immigration Attorneys

Hermie Wentzel

Co-Founder & Senior Attorney

Our offices

Johannesburg & Cape Town – one firm

Two offices, one standard of work. Consultations in person by appointment, or by phone and video call wherever you are in South Africa or abroad.

Johannesburg

Johannesburg Office

Cape Town

Cape Town Consultation Facility

FAQs

Questions clients ask us

Straight answers from immigration attorneys. Every case is different, so treat these as a starting point – not legal advice for your specific matter.

How long do I have to bring a judicial review?

Under PAJA, generally within 180 days after internal remedies are concluded or after you became aware of the decision and its reasons. Late reviews require condonation.

Do I have to appeal to the Minister first?

Usually yes. PAJA requires internal remedies to be exhausted unless the court grants an exemption in exceptional circumstances.

Can the court grant my visa?

Normally the court sets aside the decision and sends it back to Home Affairs to decide lawfully. Substitution is reserved for exceptional cases.

What is the record of decision?

Under Rule 53, Home Affairs must provide the documents it relied on. The record often reveals the real reason for a refusal.

Is judicial review the same as an appeal?

No. An appeal reconsiders the merits; a review tests whether the decision-making was lawful, reasonable and fair.

Book a consultation

Tell us your story

Send your details and an attorney’s office will contact you with a booking date. A consultation fee applies and depends on the type of case – it is confirmed with you before anything is booked.

Request a consultation

Fields marked * are required. Everything you send is confidential.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Your information is used only to respond to your enquiry. We will contact you with a booking date; the consultation fee depends on your case and is confirmed before booking.

Find us

Visit us in Johannesburg or Cape Town

Johannesburg Office

9th Floor, Bedford Centre Office Tower, Cnr Smith Road & Van de Linde Road, Bedfordview, Johannesburg, 2008

Directions

Loading map…

Cape Town Consultation Facility

Junction, Cnr Stanley Road & Dock Road, V&A Waterfront, Cape Town City Centre, Cape Town, 8001

Directions

Loading map…

South African immigration attorneys in Johannesburg and Cape Town. Visas, permits, permanent residence, appeals, waivers, V-list and overstay matters, and High Court litigation against Home Affairs – with 40+ years of combined experience.

Johannesburg

Cape Town

Firm

Wentzel Immigration Attorneys is a private law practice and is not affiliated with the Department of Home Affairs or VFS Global. Information on this website is general and is not legal advice for your specific matter. All visa and permit decisions are made by the Department of Home Affairs.

© 2026 Wentzel Immigration Attorneys. All rights reserved.SEO & MarketingPowered by WebproX